ClickMagick Review (2024): Is This The Best Click Tracking Solution?

One of the biggest mistakes new marketers make is to treat click and conversion tracking like an afterthought. In reality, it’s critically important.

In order to maximize profits and grow your business, you need to know where your traffic is coming from and how it’s responding to your offers.

You need a way to track your conversions and measure the performance of all your campaigns and ads so that you can find out what’s working and what isn’t. 

And for all that, you need click tracking software.

In this ClickMagick review, we’ll be taking a look at one of the most popular link tracking software solutions on the market. We’ll be explaining what ClickMagick is, how it works, and all the things you can do with it. 

We’re also going to share what we think are its main pros and cons, discuss pricing options (and whether or not it’s worth the money), and much more. 

By the end of this post, you’ll know whether or not ClickMagick is the right platform for your needs. Let’s get started.

What Is ClickMagick?

ClickMagick is one of the most comprehensive tracking tools on the market. It’s more than just a link tracker—it’s an all-in-one marketing analytics solution that provides you with everything you need to track, test, and optimize your entire sales funnel.

It was founded in 2014 and has been used by over 122,000 entrepreneurs and small businesses to date.

The core purpose of ClickMagick is to show you who’s clicking your links, which sources those clicks are coming from, and which of those clicks are leading to sales. Once you’re armed with this data, you can use it to better optimize your marketing efforts.

For example, you’ll be able to tell whether or not a certain ad campaign is generating the expected number of sales and delivering a positive return on investment (ROI).

And if not, you can shut it down and redirect your time and money into traffic sources that are more profitable.

You’ll also be able to find out things like which of the links on your landing pages are getting the most clicks, what kind of traffic quality you’re getting from your email campaigns, and see all of your key marketing metrics in one place. 

And since it’s completely cloud-based, you can do everything you need to do from one easy-to-use web portal. You can set up all your link and campaign tracking and monitor all the links you’ve entered into the system from your online dashboard.

Of course, this is only just scratching the surface of what you can do with ClickMagick. It’s jam-packed with other advanced features that marketers and online businesses will find useful, which we’ll explore in more detail shortly.

Who Is ClickMagick For?

The ClickMagick link tracking tool is built for:

• Affiliate marketers
• Businesses selling their own products or services
• Solo ad sellers (and buyers)
• Lead generation experts
• Bloggers
• Marketing agencies
• Content creators & influencers (you can track clicks through YouTube, Instagram bios, etc.)
• Anyone running paid ads.

ClickMagick Review Features

ClickMagick has a very broad feature set. There’s a lot you can do with it, so we’re just going to focus on what we think are the most important features.

Tracking Links

Tracking Links are pretty much the ‘core’ feature of ClickMagick. They’re basically custom links that track clicks and collect data about the visitors who pass through them (e.g. where they’re located, the device they’re using, etc.).

They work using URL redirects, which means that when a visitor clicks the link, their browser immediately redirects them to the destination URL (that’s your landing page), and their information is tracked.

The only problem is that major ad networks like Google and Facebook Ads don’t like URL redirects. Therefore, you should use the Campaigns feature to track clicks through these channels instead (more on this later). In all other cases, you can use Tracking Links. 

Creating a new tracking link couldn’t be easier. From your dashboard, just switch to the Links tab and click on New Link. Now all you need to do is choose a name for the link, add your URL and link slug, and you’re done.

ClickMagick will then automatically track anyone that goes through the link.

Of course, this is all very basic stuff that you can do with pretty much any link tracker or URL generator (even the free ones). However, what makes ClickMagick special is all the advanced settings you can apply. 

We won’t go into detail about all of these settings just yet as we’ll be covering many of them later in this review, but here’s a sneak-peak:

From the tabs shown here, you can add pixel codes (essential for retargeting), set up geotargeting options, filter out unwanted clicks, and much more.

Targeting Options

One of the coolest things about ClickMagick is its targeting features.

You can set up your Tracking Links and Rotators to send your visitors to different landing pages based on the type of device they’re using or their geographical location.

For example, you might want to send visitors from different counties to localized versions of your landing pages in their own language and currency or only include tier 1 countries in certain Tracking Links. 

Or, you might want to send mobile or tablet users to mobile-optimized versions of your site.

This can help you to create a more personalized user experience and significantly increase your conversion rates.

Sub-IDs

Another thing we really liked about ClickMagick is its support for sub-IDs—something most other link tracking solutions lack.

Sub-IDs are unique identifiers that enable you to track clicks on a granular level.

For example, let’s say I have a landing page with multiple ‘buy now’ button links: one at the top, in the middle, and at the bottom of the page, and I want to track clicks to each of those button links independently.

With most other link trackers, I’d have to create separate tracking links for each button, but with ClickMagick, I can just use one tracking link and add multiple sub-IDs. All I have to do is append an ID for each button to the end.

For example, if my regular tracking link was:

https://www.clkmg.com/example/linkSlug

I could add a sub-ID for the top button like this:

https://www.clkmg.com/example/linkSlug/Button1

Once I’ve set up my sub-IDs, I’ll be able to identify which clicks came through each button and which led to conversions in my sub-ID stats and reports.

You can open up the report by clicking on the first icon to the right of your tracking link and selecting Sub-ID Stats.

Campaign Tracking

As we mentioned briefly earlier, Google Ads and Facebook Ads don’t like cross-domain redirects, so regular tracking links won’t work for your ad campaigns.

Fortunately, that’s what the Campaigns feature is for. It allows you to track traffic and conversions from your ad campaign clicks via industry-standard UTM codes and first-party cookies. No tracking links or redirects are required.

And it’s pretty easy to set up.

To start tracking your campaigns, the first step is to add the click tracking code to your landing pages and the conversion tracking code to your ‘thank you’ page or any other page where you want to track important actions or sales. 

Then, create UTMs for your landing page URL to use in your ad campaigns (this is usually done via a tracking template in Google/Facebook ads dashboard).

And once you’ve done that, simply launch your campaign and start driving traffic, and ClickMagick will take care of the rest.

It’ll automatically track your paid ad, PPC, and other promotional link clicks and slice and dice the data for you. 

At a glance, you’ll be able to see key metrics like visitors, ROI, ad spend, opt-in and conversion rates, average order value, lifetime customer value, revenue, etc., for every traffic source and campaign.

You can view graphs for any metric just by clicking on them.

Cross-Device Tracking

These days, it seems that more or less everyone has a bunch of different devices that they switch between throughout the day.

They might use their mobile phone while they commute, their desktop at work, laptop at the coffee shop, and tablet at home.

This makes it difficult to track your visitor’s true activity. Many link trackers can’t tell when the same visitor accesses your website on a different device.

To the software, it looks like you’ve had three different clicks from three different unique visitors. But in reality, it’s all the same person. This can lead to misleading data.

Fortunately, this isn’t a problem with ClickMagick.

It offers true cross-device tracking, which means you’ll be able to monitor your visitors’ behavior regardless of what device they access your website on and can have confidence that your data is accurate. 

External Page Tracking

Most websites are set up so that when one of your website visitors converts (i.e. makes a purchase or opts into a form), they’re sent to a ‘thank you’ page. 

As we mentioned briefly earlier, ClickMagick (and most other link tracking software) track your website conversions by adding a conversion pixel to this thank you page.

The conversion pixel fires whenever someone is directed to the page and tells ClickMagick that a conversion has just taken place.

The only problem is that in order to add that all-important conversion pixel to your page, you need access to the website code.

This isn’t an issue if you own the domain, but what if you’re an affiliate marketing who’s sending traffic to an external domain that you don’t own?

Well, ClickMagick thought of that too and has implemented a neat workaround.

You can set it up so that when somebody converts on the other domain, they’ll first be very briefly sent to a blank page with your conversion pixel on, then redirected to the external page. 

It all happens very quickly, and the user won’t even notice, but ClickMagick will know a conversion’s taken place. 

Rotators

Rotators are links that distribute your traffic to different destination pages the way you want them to. 

If you’ve ever run a split testing campaign, it’s kind of similar to that, except you’re not testing anything – you’re just distributing traffic. 

You can choose the way you want traffic to be distributed by setting the Rotator Mode. For example, you might want to distribute click traffic to different landing pages:

• Sequentially: The first click is sent to page A, the second click to page B, the third click to page C, and the fourth click back to page A again, then the pattern repeats. 
• Randomly: Clicks are distributed at random to all the included pages.
• By order fulfillment: Clicks are sent solely to the first page in the rotator until it’s reached a specified amount of clicks.

Again, you have a lot of control over your rotators in the advanced settings. You can set individual rules for things like geotargeting and traffic quality. 

Split Testing

You can also set up and run A/B tests using ClickMagick.

To do so, all you have to do is click the spanner icon next to any Tracking Link and select Split Testing. You’ll then be brought to the Split Testing settings page.

Here, you can add as many page variations as you like and set the ‘weight’ to specify the portion of your traffic that you want to allocate to each of them.

You can also set what you want to optimize for: actions, engagements, sales, or earnings per click. 

You can start running traffic once you’ve done that, and ClickMagick will automatically look for a winner. 

ClickShield (Bot Blocker)

Whenever you run ad campaigns, it’s inevitable that at least some of your clicks will be coming from bots (software programs) or, worse, competitors trying to drive up your costs.

These types of clicks don’t convert to sales and do nothing but drive up your ad spend. 

Fortunately, ClickMagick’s Click Shield feature can help you to combat bot traffic and worse.

You can set up fraud monitoring traffic quality rules to define what kind of clicks you want and what kind of clicks you want to block. The result is more effective campaigns at a lower cost. 

Offline Conversion Tracking

ClickMagick isn’t just for online conversion tracking—you can also use it to track your offline and phone conversions.

In fact, ClickMagick is one of the only platforms suitable for small businesses that enable you to track offline conversions.

To set up offline conversion tracking, select it from the Tools dropdown menu.

Then, you’ll need to record any conversions you generate offline by entering the customer or prospect’s visitor ID or click ID to Offline Conversions.

The conversion will then be attributed to the relevant Tracking Link or Campaigns project. 

It’s as easy as that. Just note that this feature is usually used by businesses that have CRMs or autoresponders. More details here.

Traffic Quality Score

Another cool thing ClickMagick can do is assess your traffic quality.

The platform will automatically assign a unique Traffic Quality Score to every link you set up.

And, if your Quality Score seems lower than expected, it’ll notify you so that you can investigate.

This can help you to determine which of your traffic sources are most profitable.

It’s especially useful if you’re running solo ads as it can be tough to find reliable, trustworthy vendors. 

Alerts and Notifications

Suspicious traffic quality isn’t the only thing ClickMagick can notify you about. You can actually set up alerts and notifications for any of your tracking links.

To do so, click the spanner icon next to any of your tracking links, then select Link Notifications. You’ll then see a settings page like this:

Here, you can choose when you want to be notified by email about your link performance by setting up a simple ‘If X, then Y’ automation.

You have a bunch of options here and can choose between triggers like:

• Action conversion rate
• Engagement conversion rate
• Sales conversion rate
• Earnings per click
• Average customer value

Once you’ve selected your trigger, you can input the figure it has to be less than or greater than before the notification is sent and the number of clicks required.

For example, if your expected action conversion rate is around 3%-6%, you might want to set it up so that you get a notification if it drops below 2%.

This can function as a kind of early warning system to tell you that something has likely gone wrong.

And the sooner you know there’s a problem, the sooner you can fix it.

Attribution Modeling

ClickMagic is great for affiliate marketing as it provides advanced attribution models.

By default, it uses the ‘last click’ attribution model, in which credit for the conversion goes to the affiliate whose link was clicked last before the sale.

However, if you want to mix it up, you can. You can choose between various models, including:

• First click
• Linear
• Position-based
• Time-decay
• Last click

Other ClickMagick Features Worth Mentioning

There’s a lot more you can do with ClickMagick, and a bunch of other features we could talk at length about (aside from the above), but we just don’t have time to cover them all.

That said, here’s a quick overview of some of the other features available:

• Batch Editor
• Affiliate marketing tools
• Audience optimization
• Facebook API integration
• Click ID Lookup
• Custom Postbacks
• Click ID Lookup
• Data Importer and Exporter
• Record Phone Sale
• IP Lookup/Manager
• Postback URLs Builder/Debugger
• Tracking Pixel Builder

ClickMagick Support & Documentation

ClickMagick can be a little overwhelming when you first start using it. After all, there’s a lot to learn. But fortunately, support is at hand to help you every step of the way.

When you first access your dashboard, you’ll be greeted with a 2-minute video to help you get started, based on how you want to use ClickMagick.

And that’s not all. You’ll also be given access to a whole library of even more video tutorials that show you how to do just about everything. 

In addition to videos, you also get access to the ClickMagick Knowledgebase, which is a huge repository of tutorials, FAQs, guides, and other educational materials that teach you how to use the platform. 

Within the platform itself, you’ll also notice handy tooltips that appear on more or less every page, like this:

And if all that isn’t enough, you can also reach out to a real human for support via email. Standard and Pro customers can get live chat support during operating hours (around 18 hours per day), as well as phone support if needed.

Alternatively, ticket support is available 24/7 for less urgent queries. You can submit your request via the help desk, and you should receive a response within a few hours. 

And the best part is, the support reps you speak to are real, US-based marketers with years of experience, so they know how to help.

Unlike other providers, ClickMagick doesn’t outsource their customer support to low-paid, inexperienced reps who can only read off a script. 

One final point worth mentioning is that you can also join the public ClickMagick Facebook group.

It’s a helpful community with thousands of other users, so if you have questions, then chances are there will be someone on there with the answers. 

ClickMagick Review – Pros and Cons

Pros

• Advanced tracking features
• Complete sales funnel tracking (Campaigns feature)
• UTMs and first-party cookies
• Automatic bot filtering and blocking
• Traffic scoring
• New features are added every month
• Fantastic support and documentation
• Sub-IDs

Cons

• High learning curve (due to advanced/complex features)
• No live chat support on the lowest price plan
• No free plan is available

ClickMagick Pricing Plans

There are three ClickMagick pricing plans to choose from:

• Starter plan: Up to 10,000 clicks/month, 1 team member, 2 custom tracking domains, TrueTracking Platform, stats, and metrics, funnel tracking (1 project), ticket support, 6 months data retention
• Standard plan: Up to 100,000 clicks/month, 3 team members, 10 custom tracking domains cross-device tracking, advanced attribution model, phone/offline sales tracking, audience optimization, Click Shield, live chat/phone/helpdesk support, kickoff call, plus everything included in the Starter Plan.
• Pro plan: Up to 1 million clicks/month, unlimited everything, “done for you” support (ClickMagick will take care of the problem for you), 2-year data retention, free paid traffic training courses, and everything included in the Standard plan.

Read our full ClickMagick pricing guide.

As you can see, the Starter Plan misses out on some features that I’d consider very important for most businesses (like cross-device tracking and Click Shield), so the Standard plan is probably going to be the best choice in most instances. 100k clicks per month should be more than sufficient for most users. 

And if you have more clicks than that, then the jump up in price up to the Pro plan will probably be negligible compared to your revenue figures.

ClickMagick Review – Is It Worth It?

So, let’s get to the big question: should you invest in ClickMagick?

If you do any sort of online marketing, I’d say yes—probably.

It’s essential to know where your clicks and conversions are coming from to continually optimize your campaigns and prioritize the most profitable channels. 

You might be able to make do with basic free alternatives like Google Analytics—or with the stats provided by your ad networks and autoresponder software, etc.—but there’s a limit to what you can do with these solutions; you’ll likely soon outgrow them.

Plus, you can never be certain that the data you’re getting is 100% accurate and tells the whole picture.

Conversely, ClickMagick gives you pinpoint accuracy and provides access to all your key marketing metrics in one single dashboard. 

And there are other reasons to invest in ClickMagick too.

For example, the bot click filtering feature can help you save money on your ad campaigns—money that you’d basically be throwing away without it.

And over time, those savings add up. If you’re running a ton of PPC campaigns, ClickMagick could pay for itself with this feature alone.

ClickMagick Alternatives

With our review out of the way, investing it ultimately depends on your business, budget, and priorities.

If ClickMagick isn’t the right link tracking software for you, there are plenty of similar alternatives out there that you might want to check out instead.

Here are some of our favorites.

1. ClickMeter

ClickMeter is another tracking solution like ClickMagick that enables you to track all of your marketing links in one place.

It has a similar tiered pricing system, but its starter plan is a little more affordable and includes up to 25,000 clicks/month (compared to ClickMagick’s 10,000 clicks/month).

2. Voluum

Voluum is another market leader and popular alternative to ClickMagick. It’s ideal for tracking ad campaigns and affiliate links, with a similar feature set to ClickMagick. It’s also cloud-based, like ClickMagick.

3. Improvely

Improvely is marketed as both a conversion tracking solution and click fraud monitoring tool. Like ClickMagick, it can help you to both track clicks and eliminate false clicks from bots that skew your analytics and ruin your PPC campaigns. 

ClickMagick Review FAQs

Before we wrap up this ClickMagick review, here are some answers to commonly asked questions about the platform.

How Does ClickMagick Work?

ClickMagick works by allowing you to set up UTMs, tracking links, rotators, and tracking pixels.

These tools can grab data from website visitors that click your links and generate insights that will help you run better marketing campaigns. 

Is ClickMagick Free?

Unfortunately, ClickMagick doesn’t offer a free plan. However, they offer a 14-day free trial, which you can use to try it out before buying.

You’ll have access to all the core features during the trial period. Just bear in mind that you’ll need to enter your credit card details in order to sign up, but as long as you cancel before the trial period is over, you won’t be charged.

How Do I Track My emails with ClickMagick?

The easiest way to track clicks through your marketing emails is to use ClickMagick’s Tracking Links feature.

Simply create a separate link or sub-ID (see the features section of this post for instructions) for every link you want to add to the email. Once you’ve sent the email, you can view the stats on the reports page in the dashboard.

Does ClickMagick have an iOS app?

Not yet, but there may be one soon. According to a representative on the ClickMagick Facebook group, they’re currently working on their public API release, which will power their mobile app.

Final Thoughts On ClickMagick

That concludes our in-depth ClickMagick review.

We hope this has helped you get a better understanding of everything that the ClickMagick click tracking platform has to offer (when compared to the other Clickmagick reviews out there) and decide whether it’s the right solution for your business.

If you’re an affiliate marketer using tracking multiple links through software such as Bitly or Prettylinks, I recommend making the switch to ClickMagick.

You’ll be able to house all your tracking links in one dashboard, see key insights such as affiliate sales, and it makes monitoring traffic quality analysis much clearer.

If you’re just starting out with affiliate marketing, you might also want to check out our beginner’s guide to making money as an affiliate marketer. 

Good luck!